Elvis Presley died nearly half a century ago, but the songs he made famous are now the subject of a $48.6 million copyright dispute involving one of the world's leading artificial intelligence companies.
The owners of rights to 274 musical compositions recorded by Presley have sued Anthropic, alleging that the company copied their lyrics without permission to train Claude, its AI chatbot, and subsequently allowed the software to reproduce or rewrite protected material.
The lawsuit, filed on October 23 in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, names ABG EPE IP LLC, two music publishers, several family trusts and an individual rights holder as plaintiffs.
Their catalogue includes Can't Help Falling in Love, All Shook Up, Don't Be Cruel, Return to Sender and A Little Less Conversation. Although these songs are associated with Presley, many were written by other composers whose publishing rights remain commercially valuable.
That distinction is important. The lawsuit principally concerns copyrights in musical compositions, particularly lyrics, rather than ownership of Presley's voice, image or original sound recordings.
According to the plaintiffs, Anthropic collected copyrighted lyrics from online sources, retained copies in an internal repository and used them to develop successive versions of Claude. They further allege that the company's data-processing methods removed information identifying songwriters, publishers and copyright owners.
The complaint also addresses what Claude produces for users. The rights holders claim that Anthropic introduced restrictions after earlier copyright disputes, but that users could still obtain substantially similar versions of protected songs by requesting adaptations for contemporary audiences.
The plaintiffs allege that Claude sometimes generated rewrites retaining recognisable elements of the original compositions despite changes to the words. They cite these outputs as evidence that the company's safeguards are inadequate.
Anthropic disputes the allegations. In a statement reported on October 25, a company spokesperson said the company disagreed with the claims and intended to defend the case.
The plaintiffs are seeking $41.1 million in statutory copyright damages, calculated at $150,000 for each of the 274 compositions. They also request $685,000 for alleged circumvention of technological protections and $6.85 million for allegedly removing copyright-management information, bringing their specified claims to approximately $48.6 million.
Financial compensation is only part of the requested remedy. The lawsuit asks the court to order Anthropic to account for the disputed training materials and destroy or surrender unauthorised copies allegedly retained in datasets, internal repositories and other infrastructure.
The case joins an expanding series of music-industry lawsuits against Anthropic. Publishers including Concord Music Group and BMG Rights Management have brought separate proceedings involving copyrighted song lyrics.
The legal questions extend beyond whether Claude can reproduce a familiar song. US copyright law grants owners exclusive rights over protected compositions, but it also recognises exceptions, including fair use. Whether particular forms of AI training qualify for those exceptions remains contested.
There is a commercial complication, too. Some of Presley's recordings are almost 70 years old, but the underlying compositions can remain protected independently of the recordings themselves. Rights holders continue to license those works for performances, films, advertisements and other uses.
The new case will test whether Anthropic's alleged acquisition, retention and use of the lyrics crossed copyright boundaries. The plaintiffs also want access to information about the material used to train Claude, which could help establish whether their songs were copied and how extensively.
For now, the allegations remain unproven. Anthropic has rejected them, and the court has not determined whether its use of the disputed works constitutes infringement.